Cast Iron vs Cast Steel: The Difference That Reaches the Drawing

Jun 18th, 2025

Cast Iron vs Cast Steel: The Difference That Reaches the Drawing

Cast iron contains 2 to 4 percent carbon. Cast steel contains less than 2, usually 0.2 to 0.6 percent for a structural grade.

That single line decides how the metal freezes, and everything a buyer notices later follows from it: how much the pattern has to be scaled up, how much metal is poured into risers and cut off as scrap, whether the part can be welded on site, and how it behaves when it is dropped at minus 20 °C.

The 2 percent line is real, the boundary is not

The metallurgical division is not a carbon number. It is the carbon equivalent, roughly C + Si/3 + P/3. Iron sits at or above the eutectic around 4.3, which means graphite forms during solidification. Steel sits well below it, so it freezes without free graphite.

That is the whole mechanism. Graphite in iron does three things at once: it makes the material machine easily, it absorbs vibration, and it gives the casting a way to feed its own shrinkage. It also interrupts the metal matrix, which is why iron has almost no elongation.

FamilyCarbon, percentCommon gradesTensile, MPaElongation, percent
Gray iron2.5 to 4.0HT200, HT250, HT300; A48 Class 30 to 50150 to 4000.3 to 0.8
Ductile iron3.0 to 4.0QT400-18 to QT700-2; A536 60-40-18 to 100-70-03400 to 7002 to 18
Cast carbon steel0.2 to 0.6WCB, WCC (A216)485 to 65522 minimum
Cast stainless0.03 to 0.30CA15, CA6NM550 to 80015 to 20

Two rows break the pattern most buyers expect. Ductile iron at 700 MPa is stronger in tension than WCB across most of its range, and it is still not a steel, because its elongation and its stiffness sit in a different place. More on that below.

The numbers that reach the drawing

Chemistry is the foundry's problem. These are the properties that end up in a design calculation or a purchasing decision.

PropertyGray ironDuctile ironCast carbon steel
Tensile strength150 to 400 MPa400 to 700 MPa485 to 655 MPa
Yield or 0.1 percent proofNot used in design250 to 600 MPa250 MPa minimum
Elongation0.3 to 0.8 percent10 to 18 percent22 percent minimum
Elastic modulus100 to 150 GPa169 to 176 GPa200 GPa
Impact at minus 20 °CBrittleGrade dependent, ferritic grades acceptableGood
DampingHighMediumLow
Thermal conductivity45 to 50 W/m·K30 to 38 W/m·K30 to 40 W/m·K
MachinabilityBest of the threeGoodPoorest
WeldabilityNot structuralLimited, with preheat and nickel electrodeGood, with preheat and controlled procedure
Pattern shrink allowance0.8 to 1.0 percent0.7 to 1.0 percent1.6 to 2.0 percent
Pouring temperature1,320 to 1,400 °C1,350 to 1,450 °C1,550 to 1,620 °C
Minimum wall3 to 4 mm3 to 4 mm5 to 8 mm

Read the modulus row before the strength row. Stiffness does not follow strength, and the gap between 170 GPa and 200 GPa is the mistake that ruins more substitutions than any other single number.

Why cast steel costs more per kilogram

Steel is more expensive than iron per finished part before anyone adds a margin, and the reason is not the alloy cost.

Riser yield. Steel has no graphite expansion to feed its own shrinkage, so every shrinkage cavity has to be fed from a riser that is itself poured, solidified and cut off. A steel casting typically ships 50 to 60 percent of the metal poured. Iron ships 70 to 80 percent. To deliver 100 kg of good castings you melt about 130 kg of iron or about 180 kg of steel, and the difference is paid at the furnace, in the ladle, in the cleaning bay and in the scrap rebate.

Pouring temperature. 1,550 to 1,620 °C against 1,350 to 1,450 °C is 200 °C of extra superheat. That is more energy per tonne, faster refractory wear, shorter ladle life and a hotter working floor. Steel foundries also usually heat treat, because a casting that cools in the mould has a coarse as-cast structure and residual stress, so a normalise or anneal is a process step iron often does not need.

Shrink allowance. A 2 percent pattern shrink on a 400 mm dimension is 8 mm of scale, and the machining stock that goes with it is thicker and less forgiving. A steel casting that moves in the mould has less room to be recovered by machining.

Inspection. Structural steel castings are usually 100 percent magnetic particle or ultrasonic tested, and often radiographed at section changes. That is a real cost per part, and it exists because the failure mode is a brittle one.

Put together, a WCB casting commonly lands at 1.5 to 2.5 times the price of a ductile iron casting of the same finished weight, and the ratio gets worse as the part gets heavier because the riser yield dominates. The green sand guide explains how the mould, not the metal, sets the feeding rule on the iron side.

Four cases where the answer flips

Most material comparisons stop at a property table. The decision is usually made by one of four specific duties, and in each one a different material wins.

Impact at low temperature. A hitch component, a rail clip, a cold-climate machine part. Gray iron is out at any price, because it has essentially no elongation and its fracture is brittle. Cast steel is the safe answer. A ferritic ductile iron grade such as QT400-18 with impact testing at minus 20 °C is a legitimate alternative and is often cheaper, but it has to be specified with the impact test, not assumed from the grade number.

Vibration and stiffness. A machine tool bed, a press frame, a pump base. Gray iron wins, and not because it is strong. Its damping capacity is several times that of steel, so the resonance that would ring through a welded or cast steel frame dies in the iron. Its modulus is lower, but the section can be made thicker for less money than the steel part costs, and the finished machine is quieter.

Pressure boundary. A pump housing at 16 bar of water is ductile iron, and this is most of what we pour. Steam above 350 °C, or a pressure part that sees thermal cycling, is cast steel, because iron loses strength earlier and its thermal conductivity does not save it at those temperatures.

Field repair. A cracked housing on a machine that cannot be removed from site. Cast steel can be welded with a qualified procedure, preheat and a controlled cool. Gray iron weld repair is cosmetic and localised, and a structural weld on gray iron is a repair that will fail next to the weld. Ductile iron sits in between: weldable with a nickel electrode, preheat and short passes, and only for non-critical sections.

The substitution mistake: matching tensile strength

A buyer with a WCB bracket sees that QT450-10 is rated at 450 MPa and concludes the iron is equivalent. The numbers look close. The part then deflects more than the calculation predicted, or cracks at a section change, and the iron gets blamed.

Three things go wrong in that comparison.

The modulus is 170 GPa against 200 GPa, so an identical section is 15 percent less stiff in ductile iron. If the bracket was designed for deflection, the section has to grow, and if it was designed into a fixed envelope, growing the section may not be possible.

Elongation is 10 percent against 22 percent, so the iron has less capacity to redistribute a local stress peak. A steel part tolerates a sharp corner that an iron part will crack at, which is why fillets matter more on iron.

Fatigue is not in either table. Gray iron is notch-insensitive because the graphite flakes blunt a crack tip, ductile iron is moderately sensitive, and steel is sensitive to surface finish. A steel part that was shot-peened for fatigue life does not become an iron part by changing the material callout.

The substitution that does work is the other direction: a ductile iron part replacing a steel weldment or a steel casting, where the design can absorb 10 to 15 percent more weight and the duty is not impact at low temperature. That conversion is usually a third cheaper and removes a fabrication route, and we quote it often.

How a grade is verified before it ships

A grade callout on a drawing is a claim, and a claim needs a test. On an iron part we run four.

Chemistry comes off the spectrometer on every heat, before the pour, and the carbon equivalent is calculated from it rather than from a nomogram on the wall.

Nodularity is measured on a sample poured from the treated ladle. The production floor for ductile iron is 85 percent, and pressure or structural parts are held at 90 percent or above. This is the test that separates a QT450-10 from a casting that merely has the right chemistry.

Tensile properties come from a separately cast test bar, not from the part, because a test bar machined out of a casting measures the casting's section rather than the grade. Elongation is the number that fails first when the magnesium treatment has faded or the inoculation was late.

Hardness is checked on the part, and microstructure is examined when the grade has a ferrite or pearlite requirement, because two castings at the same tensile strength can have very different machining behaviour.

A cast steel part needs the same discipline plus impact testing at the specified temperature and a weld procedure qualification if the part will be welded in service. When a substitution goes wrong, it usually surfaces as a scrap batch long before it surfaces in service, and the scrap rate analysis shows how that cost lands. If a supplier cannot produce those documents, the grade on the certificate is an opinion.

Where we stop

We pour gray and ductile iron. We do not pour cast steel, and this page is not an argument that iron is better.

If the drawing says WCB, WCC or CA6NM, we say so in the first reply. The iron casting parts page lists the part families we do quote. Brokering it through another foundry and adding a margin would make the price look normal and the accountability invisible, which is worse for both of us.

What we will do is check whether the duty actually requires steel. About one drawing in five that arrives as a steel casting is a candidate for ductile iron, and we will show the calculation: the section that has to grow for stiffness, the weight that adds, and the cost that comes out. Sometimes the answer is that the section cannot grow and the steel stays.

FAQ

Is ductile iron stronger than cast steel?

In tension, sometimes. QT700-2 is rated at 700 MPa and common WCB at 485 to 655 MPa. In elongation, toughness and stiffness, no: ductile iron gives 10 to 18 percent elongation against 22 percent minimum for WCB, and 170 GPa against 200 GPa. A design that needs deflection control or impact resistance will not accept the substitution on strength alone.

Can cast iron be welded?

Gray iron cannot be welded structurally. A localised cosmetic repair with a nickel electrode is possible and will pass a visual check, but the heat-affected zone is brittle and a structural weld will crack next to the weld bead. Ductile iron can be welded for non-critical sections with preheat and short passes. Cast steel welds normally with a qualified procedure.

What is the carbon content of cast iron and cast steel?

Cast iron is 2 to 4 percent carbon, with 1 to 3 percent silicon. Cast steel is under 2 percent, typically 0.2 to 0.6 percent for a structural grade, and up to about 1.2 percent for a high-carbon wear grade. The silicon matters as much as the carbon, because it promotes graphite formation in iron.

Which is cheaper, cast iron or cast steel?

Iron, per finished kilogram and by a wider margin per finished part. A steel casting ships 50 to 60 percent of the metal poured because risers cannot be avoided; iron ships 70 to 80 percent. Add the higher pouring temperature, the heat treatment and the mandatory NDT, and a WCB part typically lands at 1.5 to 2.5 times the ductile iron price for the same finished weight.

Can ductile iron replace cast steel?

In low-impact duties where the design can absorb 10 to 15 percent more weight, often yes, and it is usually cheaper. It fails where the part needs impact resistance below minus 20 °C, where stiffness is the governing calculation, or where the part must be welded in service.

Why does cast steel need bigger risers than cast iron?

Because steel does not grow graphite as it solidifies. Iron's graphite expansion partly compensates for liquid and solidification shrinkage, so a smaller riser can feed the same section. Steel shrinks throughout and every cavity has to be fed from a reservoir that is poured and then cut off as scrap.

Before you send the drawing

State the material by standard designation rather than a trade name, and state the duty: is the governing case strength, stiffness, impact, pressure or wear? A grade chosen for the wrong governing case is the most expensive mistake in this comparison, because it is invisible until the part is in service.

If you have a steel casting that you suspect could be iron, send the drawing and the duty and we will run the conversion arithmetic. The ductile iron grade list shows what we pour, the process comparison covers which process suits which geometry, and the defect guide explains how the failures in this article actually appear on a part.

Product Reviews

0

nico@zyqfoundry.com

82b6bea3fa8b013700d5b8cb6263e9a
82b6bea3fa8b013700d5b8cb6263e9a

86-18561567088

86-18561567088